DigaPixBlog

Critiquing, judging and Scoring of Photographs

Posted by JL Morris on June 27, 2008

Fire Island Lighthouse

Posted under Architecture, Color, Critiqued

Fire Island LighthouseA writer for Time magazine meets a photographer working for National Geographies in a bar.  The writer says to the photographer “I saw your spread in last month’s issue.  The photographs were great.  What camera did you use?” To this the photographer replies “Well I read your article last month and it was wonderful.  What brand of typewriter did you use?” 

Too often photographers want to tell you what equipment they used to take a particular shot when it’s the image that’s important and not the method of getting there.

This image of a remarkable lighthouse uses the technique of including an interesting foreground to keep the photograph from becoming a record shot of the subject.  Too often interesting subjects are recorded without any attempt at interpretation.  This photographer was thinking “how can I make this photo different from all the rest I have seen.”  This is what I call making a photograph your own.

I like the way the subject of off center but perhaps there could be a little more room at the top.  The top of the column appears about to piers the edge of the frame.  I would also like to see this image with good morning or late afternoon light rather than the flat overcast light in this composition.

Speaking of equipment, I have seen a number of photos from this photo-artist and they all appear to have a soft quality.  I think there may be something wrong with the camera or lens.  Try taking the same shot with two different cameras and see if there is a difference in the sharpness of the results.

  Click on Image  Click to rate the movie

Fire Island Lighthouse

One Response to “Fire Island Lighthouse”

  1. Jim, Thanks for your advise, I will have my equipment checked. The photo submitted was slightly cropped before sending, however, the bottom was what I cut out, nothing from the top sad to say.

Leave a Reply

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture. Click on the picture to hear an audio file of the word.
Click to hear an audio file of the anti-spam word